Robert Beckelman

Results achieved in prior matters are not meant to be a guarantee of success as the facts and legal circumstances vary from matter to matter.

• As special redevelopment counsel for the Borough of Flemington, counseled the Borough through a novel application of a redevelopment area designation, then successfully defended a legal challenge to such redevelopment designation before the trial court, which was affirmed by the Appellate Division.
• On behalf of a national commercial real estate developer, Mr. Beckelman successfully defended in trial court (affirmed on appeal) a challenge to site plan approval for the construction of a retail establishment to be used as a Starbucks coffee shop in Rio Grande, New Jersey brought by a neighboring commercial property owner whose tenants included another Starbucks operation. At the hearings, the objector argued, among other things, that once the Middle Township Planning Board denied a parking variance, the entire application was automatically denied as a matter of law and that therefore, the Board had no authority to continue the hearing and change its interpretation of the zoning ordinance. The objector filed a complaint with the Superior Court challenging the approval. After a prerogative writ hearing, the trial court affirmed the Board’s decision and the client’s site plan approval.
• Represented the owner of a 236 unit, senior and disabled affordable housing complex in the City of Orange, negotiating the extension of a tax exemption and payment in lieu of tax (PILOT) agreement. A local resident filed a lawsuit against the City and the owner, one of over a dozen lawsuits by this plaintiff against the City, arguing that the PILOT extension was not authorized under the applicable statutes and that the City violated various municipal procedures in its approval of the PILOT. Mr. Beckelman successfully defended the case before the trial court in Essex County, which ruled in favor of the City and the owner and upheld the legality and the City's approval of the PILOT agreement. The plaintiff appealed the trial court decision, which Mr. Beckelman defended and argued on February 7, 2018. By per curiam decision on August 2, 2018, the Appellate Division affirmed the Essex trial court decision, upholding the legality of the PILOT agreement and providing assurance to the owner and the residents that the complex will continue to operate as a project-based affordable complex.
• Serves as redevelopment counsel and special litigation counsel to the City of North Wildwood in connection with complex, multi-party litigation with proceedings before the Chancery Division, the Law Division, and the Appellate Division. In a case of first impression, in connection with the bond foreclosure proceeding of Marina Bay Towers, a project financed with low income housing tax credits, the Appellate Division reversed the trial court ruling that a State affordability deed restriction was extinguished under federal regulations. The Appellate Division further affirmed the trial court ruling the deed restriction court could be extinguished or modified under the County Improvement Authorities Law, under which law the bonds were issued.  Following the Appellate Division decision, engaged in extensive multi-party mediation over several months, successfully negotiating a complex, multi-party global settlement of two cases before the Appellate Division, one before the Chancery Division and one in the Law Division.
• Served as special redevelopment, housing and litigation counsel to the City of Long Branch, the Borough of Flemington and the Township of Robbinsville.  Has also served as special litigation counsel to the City of New Brunswick and the Borough of Belmar.
• As special redevelopment counsel to the City of Long Branch, concluded negotiations for the final phase of the Pier Village project. The first two phases of the project included a mixed-use residential and retail development on Long Branch's shore front, and the development rights for the third phase were sold by Applied Development Companies to Kushner Companies in 2014 for $200 million. Since that time, Kushner substantially amended the approved phase 3 plans and the City negotiated the details of this complex project, including substantial boardwalk and public improvements and a $20 million redevelopment area bond. Kushner partnered with Extell Development to develop the phase 3 project.
• As special redevelopment counsel for the City of Long Branch, concluded negotiations for four separate residential redevelopment projects in the Beachfront South redevelopment sector, for an estimated total of $200 million of new development for that sector.
• Appeared before the Supreme Court of New Jersey, writing and filing an amicus brief in Gallenthin v. Paulsboro on behalf of the New Jersey League of Municipalities, the New Jersey Chapter of the American Planning Association, and Downtown New Jersey.
• Represented the New Jersey Association of Realtors in connection with the development of its new headquarters in Trenton, a transformative project at the site of a former industrial property. His role included establishing and negotiating the City of Trenton's first "Garden State Growth Zone" tax exemption under the Economic Stimulus Act of 2013.
• Represented the Camden Redevelopment Agency in its negotiations with the Salvation Army for the remediation, acquisition and redevelopment of a former 85-acre landfill in Camden. The location is now the site of the 120,000 square foot Ray and Joan Kroc Corps Community Center, which has brought employment opportunities, a broad range of recreational facilities and numerous additional benefits to the predominantly low-income local community since opening in October of 2014.